Can you ever have too many delicious cookie recipes? Not when Crumbl Cookies-inspired creations are involved! These copycat recipes take some of Crumbl’s most beloved flavors and recreate them at home, giving you the chance to whip up bakery-worthy treats right in your own kitchen.
Whether you’re an Oreo addict, love the chewy sweetness of caramel, or can’t resist a chocolate overload, these recipes offer something for everyone. Let’s dive into what makes each recipe special, highlight any areas to tweak for best results, and decide if they match up to that iconic pink box experience.
1. Crumbl Twix Cookies – Cooking with Karli
This recipe perfectly combines a buttery cookie base with gooey caramel and creamy chocolate, emulating the Twix candy bar flavor we all adore. It’s decadent and indulgent, just like a proper Crumbl cookie.
**The Drawback?** The caramel layer might feel overwhelmingly sweet to some, but this can easily be adjusted by reducing the caramel drizzle slightly or cutting back on the topping-to-cookie ratio.
2. Crumbl Sugar Cookies – Lemon Blossoms
A classic choice done right! This sugar cookie is soft, nostalgic, and topped with a generous layer of vanilla buttercream frosting. It’s simple but oh-so-satisfying.
**The Drawback?** The sweetness level might be over the top for some. Consider toning down the sugar, especially in the frosting, for a less cloying and more balanced result.
3. Oreo Crumbl Cookie – The Fresh Cooky
This recipe is an Oreo lover’s dream packed with Oreo chunks in the cookie dough and a silky cream cheese frosting on top. Rich, chocolatey decadence all around!
**The Drawback?** The cookies are especially dense and richly flavored—ideal for those who crave a heavy dessert but might feel overwhelming for anyone preferring a lighter option.
4. Cinnamon Roll Cookies – House of Nash Eats
If you’ve ever wanted to combine your love for warm, gooey cinnamon rolls with cookies, this recipe nails it! A soft cinnamon-spiced center and a beautiful icing drizzle make these rival even your Sunday brunch favorites.
**The Drawback?** The richness of flavor combined with the icing could be heavy for those expecting a simpler cookie experience. Adjusting the icing drizzle or portion size may make these less intense.
5. Crumbl Cosmic Brownie Cookies – The Farm Girl Gabs
A nod to nostalgia, these cookies deliver fudgy brownie goodness topped with colorful candy-coated chocolate for that playful “Cosmic” look. A hit for kids and adults alike!
**The Drawback?** Like the brownies themselves, this recipe leans on the heavier, sweeter side. Reducing the density of the chocolate base could make them more accessible to fans of lighter treats.
6. Copycat Crumbl Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies – Practically Homemade
These cookies wow with the tangy, fruity brightness of raspberry combined with the creamy dreaminess of cheesecake—and all with the added ease of a cake mix base!
**The Drawback?** The cake mix here adds convenience but might veer toward an artificial taste. If authenticity is your goal, you might swap the mix for a fully homemade base.
So, are these recipes as good as the originals? That depends on whether you’re chasing aesthetic perfection or want customizable flavors tailored to your sweet tooth! One thing’s for sure: these homemade versions deliver on flavor, fun, and all those sugary cravings.
Which of these recipes are you trying out next? Comment below and share your home-baked Crumbl creations! 🍪