Ah, brioche donuts – the crowning jewel of pastry perfection, where buttery decadence meets fluffy indulgence. Have you ever found yourself scrolling through pictures of these golden beauties online, torn between drooling uncontrollably and wondering, “Which recipe is *really* worth my time?” You’re not alone. In the tantalizing world of brioche donuts, every recipe promises unparalleled fluff, divine fillings, and that oh-so-perfect caramelized glaze—but how do you decide which one truly reigns supreme in your kitchen?
Today, we’re diving fork-first into the world of brioche donut recipes, taking a playful yet critical look at both the crowd favorites and the unexpected underdogs. Whether you’re team “keep it classic” or “let’s go wild with blackberry jam,” there’s no denying one truth: not all recipes are created equal. Is a baked brioche donut still a donut? Should a filling be pillowy cream or lip-smacking fruit jam? And more importantly, are some of these recipes worth the hours of proofing—or is quick and easy the way to go?
Get ready for a spirited breakdown of eight brioche donut recipes—from the failproof classics for beginners to indulgent creations that’ll test your baking patience (in the best way). Let’s settle the debate: are you in it for simplicity, sophistication, creativity, or that first gloriously messy bite? Fair warning: by the end of this post, you’ll probably find yourself covered in flour, frying oil, or both.
1. Kickass Baker
This recipe keeps things simple and straightforward, making it perfect for beginners eager to try their hand at brioche donuts. The step-by-step photos are super helpful! However, if you’re craving creativity, this recipe sticks to the basics, which might not satisfy those looking for a unique twist.
2. Sugar and Soul
Vanilla cream and brioche donuts? Yes, please! This recipe is spot-on for anyone who loves a creamy, melt-in-your-mouth experience. But, for those who prefer a less sweet filling, the rich vanilla might be a tad overpowering.
3. Alpine Ella
A beautifully detailed recipe that combines traditional methods with approachable tips. It’s great for bakers who love a good deep dive. If you’re in a rush, though, this one might feel a bit lengthy.
4. Girl Versus Dough
Blackberry jam brings a fruity punch to these donuts, making them a standout. It’s perfect if you love a bit of tart with your sweet. But the jam filling can be a little messy, so be prepared for sticky fingers!
5. Lil’ Cookie
These baked brioche donuts are a healthier twist on the classic. You’ll love them if you’re avoiding fried foods but still want that donut fix. Just a heads-up, baked might mean they’re less airy than their fried counterparts.
6. Pete and Gerry’s
This recipe takes homemade to heart with a focus on fresh ingredients, ideal for those who appreciate farm-to-table baking. It’s less suited for those seeking a quick whip-up, as it asks for a little extra time and love.
7. Jernej Kitchen
Rich vanilla cream filling and a fluffy donut make this a dream combo. It’s ideal for indulgence but might not be the best choice if you’re watching your calories.
8. Strawberry in the Desert
Cream-filled and luscious, this one’s all about luxury. It’s fantastic for occasionally treating yourself but with such richness, they might not be your go-to for everyday snacking.
—
FAQs About Brioche Donuts
**1. What makes brioche donuts different from regular donuts?** Brioche donuts use a dough enriched with butter and eggs, making them softer, richer, and tastier compared to regular yeasted donuts. Think of them as the elevated, luxury version of your classic fried treat.
**2. Can I bake brioche donuts instead of frying?** Absolutely! Baked brioche donuts are a great option for those looking to cut back on oil or calories. However, baking might sacrifice some of that crispy exterior and airy interior we all know and love.
**3. Which filling is the most versatile?** Vanilla cream is always a winner for its classic appeal, but jam fillings offer fruity contrast and variety. If you’re feeling bold, try experimenting with custard, chocolate ganache, or even a spiced caramel filling.
**4. Do I need special equipment to make brioche donuts?** While a stand mixer can make kneading easier, you can also knead by hand with a bit of extra effort. A thermometer is helpful for frying, and a piping bag will make filling your donuts a breeze.
**5. How do I prevent my donuts from being too oily?** Make sure your frying oil is at the right temperature (around 350°F or 175°C). If the oil is too cool, your donuts will absorb more grease. Fry in small batches to maintain optimum oil temperature.
So, which brioche donut recipe will you tackle first? Let the great debate (and baking marathon) begin!